Experience the difference of "Elite".

Choosing the Best Short-Term Rental Property Strategy

  • Published on

Choosing the Best Short-Term Rental Property Strategy

Explore the pros and cons of renting single rooms vs the entire rental property. Streamline your short-term rental management to maximize rental income.

Short-term rental strategies present property owners with unique opportunities to maximize their investment returns. By renting out individual rooms, owners can cater to budget-conscious travelers and increase occupancy rates. Conversely, renting the entire property offers guests privacy and full access to amenities, which can justify a higher price point and potentially attract a different market segment.

The choice between renting out individual rooms or an entire property depends on various factors, so property owners must consider the financial implications, legal restrictions, and personal commitments these strategies entail. By analyzing market demand, occupancy rates, operational costs, and regulatory environment, owners can make informed decisions that align with their goals. Whether focusing on individual room rentals for more steady revenue streams or whole property rentals for potentially larger yet less frequent payouts, each approach has distinct advantages and challenges.

Should I Rent Rooms Out Individually?

When looking at short-term rental strategies, property owners must weigh the pros and cons of renting spare rooms versus renting out the entire property. This decision can significantly impact rental income and operating dynamics. Let’s take a look at some of the pros and cons of individual room rentals:


- Potential for Higher Rental Income: Renting rooms can be a lucrative strategy, especially in high-demand areas. By dividing your property, say a house with a spare bedroom or two, into multiple rentable units, real estate investors often can earn more extra income than renting the entire space to a single tenant.

- Reduced Vacancy Risk: When you rent out separate rooms, you diversify your tenant base. This means if one room becomes vacant, you still generate income from the others. It also means that if you have a cancellation, you will still have income coming in from the other rooms. It's an effective way to spread your risk and maintain steady rent payments, especially in properties with significant square footage and ample common spaces.

- Enhanced Guest Interaction and Community: For some homeowners, the social aspect of renting out individual rooms is a draw. This setup can foster a sense of community and is attractive to certain audiences, like students or young professionals, potentially leading to repeat tenancy and a welcoming living environment.


- Increased Management Workload: The downside to renting out multiple rooms is the increased workload. Each tenant requires a signed rental agreement, cleaning is more frequent, and managing common areas, addressing individual concerns, and maintaining the living space can be more time-consuming and challenging than dealing with a single tenant.

- Privacy Concerns: Balancing the privacy needs of multiple tenants in a shared space can be tricky. Landlord-tenant laws and fair housing regulations must be adhered to, ensuring that all tenants feel comfortable and secure in their rental environment.

- Regulations and Restrictions: Be aware of local laws regarding room rentals. Some areas have specific regulations or require additional licensing for renting out individual rooms, which might affect your decision or require adjustments in your property management strategy.

What Should I Know About Renting My Entire Property?

Let’s now take a look at some of the pros and cons related to renting out your property as a single unit:


- Reduced Workload: Renting your investment property as a whole significantly cuts down on management efforts. Dealing with a single renter or group means fewer individual interactions, streamlined payments, and potentially less hassle regarding the maintenance of common areas and living rooms.

- Privacy and Independence for Guests: Many guests prefer the privacy of having the entire property to themselves. This setup is particularly appealing to families or groups who value having a personal and independent living space.

- Flexibility for Personal Use: Renting out the whole property provides the flexibility to seamlessly switch between a rental business and a personal retreat without the complexities of dealing with other guests or renters occupying individual rooms. This is especially beneficial for owners who view their rental property not just as an investment but also as a personal getaway.


- Lower Potential Rental Prices: The trade-off for the ease of managing a single tenant is potentially lower income. You might find that the combined rent of individual rooms exceeds the rent you can charge for the entire property, especially during off-peak seasons.

- Higher Vacancy Risk: Filling an entire property can be more challenging than renting individual rooms. This is particularly true during slower seasons, where the risk of having the whole property vacant is higher than the risk of having one unoccupied room.

- Not Ideal for All Guests: Some guests, like solo travelers or those on a budget, might prefer the affordability of renting a single room. By offering only the entire property, you might be excluding a segment of the market.

Additional Factors to Consider

When deciding between renting individual rooms or the entire property, several key factors come into play. These considerations will help you align your rental strategy with your goals, capabilities, and legal obligations.

Your Property

- Type and Layout: The nature of your rental property—be it an apartment, house, or a unique space—significantly influences your rental strategy. A property with multiple bedrooms and ample common spaces might be more suitable for room rentals, while a compact space might be better suited as a full-unit rental. Consider the square footage and how it can be utilized most effectively.

- Location and Demand: The location of your property plays a key role. Properties in tourist hotspots or near colleges may have a higher demand for short-term, room-by-room rentals. Conversely, residential areas might be more suitable for family or group rentals.

Target Audience

- Demographics and Preferences: Identify the demographic that is most likely to be attracted to your property. Families and groups might prefer the privacy of renting the entire place, while students, solo travelers, or digital nomads might look for individual rooms. Understanding your potential tenants helps tailor your offering to their needs.

Local Regulations

- Short-Term Rental and Room-Sharing Laws: Be aware of the local laws and state laws governing short-term rentals. Some areas have restrictions or specific requirements for room rentals, which can affect your ability to operate legally. This may include tenant screening, rental agreements, and adherence to fair housing practices.

- Tax Implications: Understand the tax deductions and obligations associated with each rental strategy. Income from room rentals may be treated differently by the IRS than income from renting out the entire property. Consult a tax professional to understand how this impacts your taxable income.

Personal Preferences

- Management Involvement: Consider your willingness to manage multiple tenants and the associated workload. Renting individual rooms often requires more active involvement in property management, tenant relations, and upkeep of common areas.

- Risk Tolerance: Evaluate your comfort level with the risks associated with each strategy. While renting out individual rooms can offer higher income and diversified risk, it also comes with increased potential for tenant conflicts.

- Revenue Goals: Assess your financial objectives. If maximizing income is your primary goal, renting individual rooms might be more lucrative, especially if you have a larger property in a high-demand area. However, if steady, hassle-free income is more important, renting the entire property could be more appealing.

Hybrid Strategies

Not quite sure which strategy is for you? Adopting a hybrid approach can offer the best of both worlds, allowing you to adapt to market demands and personal preferences. Here are a couple of flexible strategies to consider:

Seasonal Flexibility

Capitalize on peak seasons by renting out individual rooms to maximize your income when demand is high. During off-peak seasons, consider renting the entire property to attract longer-term tenants or families. This approach can help maintain a steady flow of income throughout the year while adapting to seasonal fluctuations in tenant demand.

Mixed Use Model

Allocate a part of your property, such as a spare bedroom, for short-term, individual room rentals while leasing the remainder of the space as a single unit. This model can be particularly effective in properties with distinct living spaces or separate entrances, allowing you to cater to different tenant groups simultaneously.

These hybrid strategies provide a dynamic way to manage your rental property, balancing the benefits of both room rentals and full-unit leases. They allow for flexibility in response to market changes, personal commitments, and tenant preferences, potentially optimizing your rental income and property usage.

Mutual Blocking

There are several different reasons you'd want a mutual block-off where blocking or booking one property blocks others.

  1. If you have adjacent properties, it's nice to offer the option to rent the combination together. You can put the combination property as an additional listing and hit higher occupancy numbers on listing sites to attract larger groups where there is typically less competition. In OwnerRez, you'd create an additional property for the combination, which allows you to set different rules and rates for that property.
  2. A property where you rent the entire property, each room separately, and also by the bed inside a room. In OwnerRez, you'd create a property for each bed, each room, and one for the entire property. When a bed is booked, the bedroom and whole house properties would be blocked. If a room is booked, the whole house and each bed inside the room would be blocked. And if the whole house is booked, everything inside it would be blocked.
  3. One physical property but multiple listings of it targeted to different audiences, each with its own OwnerRez property. When any one property is booked, the others would be blocked.

mutual blocking

Managing your Rental Properties with OwnerRez

Property management is a complex affair that benefits from the streamlined processes that we offer at OwnerRez. With automatic updates to housekeeping schedules and maintenance protocols, managers are better equipped to maintain high-quality guest services. To further facilitate operations, OwnerRez generates reports that provide insights into key performance indicators—occupancy rates and revenue among them—enabling data-driven strategy adjustments.

  • Bookings Management: Automated calendar and payment handling.
  • Multichannel Advertising: Single-platform connectivity with major rental services.
  • Operational Efficiency: Online tools facilitate housekeeping and maintenance.
  • Analytics Insight: Reporting tools measure and track business performance.
  • Customizable Tools: Tailored features to fit management needs, big or small.

The platform's per-property pricing model ensures that the cost scales sensibly with usage. Not requiring setup fees, booking fees, or binding contracts, it also offers a free 14-day trial, appealing to managers looking for flexibility and transparency in their software choices.

Embrace the professionalism and ease that OwnerRez brings to property management.